Categories: Articles

Comparing Ventilation Approaches for Pneumonia

Pneumonia is the leading infectious cause of hospitalization in US, resulting in more than 1 million admissions annually. Roughly 60% of patients with severe pneumonia develop acute respiratory failure and require invasive mechanical ventilation (IMV). Strong evidence supports the use of noninvasive mechanical ventilation (NIV) in patients with COPD or pulmonary edema, but data on its effectiveness in patients with pneumonia are conflicting.

For a study published in the Journal of Critical Care, my colleagues and I compared the outcomes of patients with pneumonia initially treated with NIV with those of patients initially treated with IMV using a large multihospital electronic medical record database that contains results of laboratory testing. We developed a propensity model for receipt of NIV and assessed the outcomes in a propensity-matched cohort.

Among nearly 4,000 patients hospitalized with pneumonia who were ventilated, 28% were treated with NIV. Mortality rates were 15.8%, 29.8%, and 25.9.0% among patients treated with initial NIV, treated with initial IMV, or who failed NIV and had to be intubated, respectively. In the propensity matched analysis, the risk of death was 30% lower in patients treated with NIV than in those treated with IMV. However, in the subgroup analysis, we showed that NIV was beneficial only among patients with cardiopulmonary comorbidities. We also found that patients with pneumonia without coexistent COPD or heart failure were more likely to fail NIV than those with cardiopulmonary conditions (21.3% vs13.8%).

Our results suggest that NIV is efficacious only in pneumonia patients who also have comorbid COPD or heart failure. Careful monitoring is required when managing severe pneumonia with NIV.


Published by
Tags: Emergency Medicine Hospital Medicine Pulmonology/Critical Care

Recent Posts

  • Reuters

South Africa’s Aspen sells Australian prescription portfolio to Mylan

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Aspen Pharmacare said on Monday that Mylan NV had exercised an option to buy the South African…

44 mins ago
  • Reuters

Back to nature: UK Duchess Kate shows off garden skills at Chelsea Flower Show

By Paul Sandle LONDON (Reuters) - Kate, Britain's Duchess of Cambridge, released new pictures of her family playing in a…

2 hours ago
  • Reuters

Investors keep food firms on warning over antibiotics

By Simon Jessop, Siddharth Cavale and Nivedita Balu LONDON (Reuters) - An investor group managing some $5 trillion said it…

3 hours ago
  • Reuters

Missouri follows Alabama by passing restrictive abortion bill

(Reuters) - Missouri lawmakers passed a bill on Friday that prohibits women from seeking an abortion after the eighth week…

2 days ago
  • Reuters

Too much screen time tied to school problems even in little kids

By Lisa Rapaport (Reuters Health) - Kindergarteners who get more than two hours of screen time a day may be…

3 days ago
  • Reuters

Smokers have higher risk for multiple strokes

By Lisa Rapaport (Reuters Health) - Smokers who have a stroke are much more likely to have another one if…

3 days ago